View unanswered posts | View active topics It is currently Mon Sep 15, 2014 9:49 pm



Reply to topic  [ 11 posts ]  Go to page 1, 2  Next
Dungeons & Dragons Starter Set Review 
Author Message

Joined: Tue Apr 28, 2009 12:50 pm
Posts: 1038
Post Dungeons & Dragons Starter Set Review
The Dungeons & Dragons Fantasy Role Playing Game Starter Set, or “new Red Box”, as it has come to be called, is an introductory boxed set to the D&D 4th edition role playing game, published by Wizards of the Coast, Inc.

This product is available in most, if not all, local gaming stores, along with some major retailers like Target, or online on Amazon.com, Noble Knight, Paizo.com and similar websites. Its suggested retail price is $19.99 US ($23.99 CAD), though it is common to find it for a cheaper amount.

For this price, you get a Player’s Book, a DM’s Book, a fold-up map of your first dungeon which later be rearranged to form later adventure sites, a set of plain black dice, a single sheet of tokens for monsters and player characters, seven sheets of detachable power and equipment cards (9 per sheet), a single sheet of advertisement laying out the different Essentials D&D products you could purchase from there depending on your role at the game table, whether player or DM, four printed character sheets, and a coupon with a code allowing you to download a follow-up, choose-your-own-path adventure from Wizards of the Coast’s online website.

Image

Contents Overview

I thought I’d try a different format for this review. Instead of describing every single chapter of the books as in a usual review for supplements or game modules, I feel it is a better approach to just take the components of the box one by one and share a few thoughts about them.

The Box, inside and out: The box itself is sturdy and rather deep. Glossy exterior, classic art everyone has commented on at this point… it is attractive, seems quite durable, and certainly has a nostalgic feel going for it. The contents within the box are held in place by a sort of cardboard wedge using about 40% of the box’s space. Though this seems like a cheap way to make you think you get more than what’s actually in there when you purchase the product, I feel that you get basically what you pay for in terms of amount or parts of content.

The Dice: these are six (with a single d10 numbered 1 to 10) solid black dice with white lettering. They feel different from usual Chessex-type dice. Their sound is clearer, and they are a little bit harder to the touch. The lettering is very large, very visible. I really like them.

Image

The Player’s Book: This book basically introduces the new player to the basic rules of the game by reading through a choose your own adventure type of text, where you get to choose what weapon to use to fight the first threat you encounter, thus determining what class your character is, then picking up this or that power, or this or that score for your stats. It all reads fairly well (which really surprised me) and is quite entertaining. There are a few instances of bad editing, like power names not matching, or references to your hit points total when, if you were not harmed at all during your first fight, you actually didn’t get to calculate it in the first place, but overall, nothing that should really stop a player dead in his or her tracks. Still, ANY editing mistake in this instance creates confusion, and confusion in an introductory product to a new hobby is just bad. This should have been avoided. By the end of the Player’s Book, you get into a fully fledged out melee against some goblins, using the dice, counters and maps included in the box, and get your first taste of what Essentials’ (and 4e’s) brand of D&D is all about. You can then help your friends read or play through the Player’s Book yourself, and upgrade to the DM’s Book to figure out how to run games for them.

Coupon for more Choose-Your-Adventure: If you want more of what was in the Player’s Book, you can download an 18-page PDF adventure from WotC’s website that basically picks up where the Player’s Book left, and before the adventure goes on via the DM’s Book. Now full disclosure, I haven’t played that adventure, but I downloaded it. It seems alright. It also uses the maps and counters of this boxed set. Seems like a cool add-on if you want to play some more solo before you decide you want to run some games for your friends.

The Tokens: These are thick, glossy, round counters a little less than one inch in diameter that help you represent your characters, your friends and foes on the battle maps. There are also a bunch of tokens for Action Points in the game. The art is good, the look is nice, and they are not confusing. Characters tokens have one side with a sort of green hue along the frame that shows your character in full health, and a side with a red hue along the frame that symbolizes your character while bloodied. Not so for the monsters. There are different types of monsters on each side of each token. So total, you end up with 5 Action points tokens, 12 different recto-verso tokens for characters, 36 tokens that represent 72 medium-sized monsters, and 3 tokens that represent 6 different large-sized monsters.

Image

The Cards: There are seven sheets of thin cardboard paper with 9 cards each (i.e. 63 cards total) that you punch out to use in the game. The cardboard is too thin for my tastes. Punching these cards out was a pain. The layout of the cards fulfills their basic function, but barely more. They are not really pleasing to the eye. These cards are probably the component of the box I liked the less. Amongst the cards you’ll find: 3 racial features cards, 4 second wind cards, 8 magic items cards, 5 fighter powers, 9 thief powers, 15 cleric powers and 19 wizard powers.

The Dungeon Master’s Book: This is where you upgrade from Player’s Book if you want to actually run games for your friends. Now, I really like the structure of this book. It starts right away where you left off with the intrigue of the Player’s Book with a first encounter that introduces concepts like Monster stats, how to run them, tactics and combat basics. Then, the book discusses how to Run The Game, explains its different game play components (with extended sections on combat, movement, actions and hit points, that sort of thing) and gets right into the meat of the thing: the sample dungeon, aka The Twisting Halls. It is a good sample that provides some straight fights, some possibilities of negotiations (and thus an introduction to skill challenges which actually made me understand some uses of skills more clearly, like how everyone’s supposed to play it loose and improvise), a cool Chess board encounter where you actually fight pawns, knight, rook and queen and are supposed to behave on the grid as chess pieces yourselves, which I thought was a pretty neat trick blurring the lines between the abstract grid combat and the actual immersion in the game, and well, more. You then get some basic guidelines on how to level up the characters to level 2, some guidelines on how to create your own adventures (including a neat trick I’m going to talk about with the battle maps), how to distribute experience and treasure, descriptions of monsters to use in said adventures however you want, and finally, a very short (two-page) primer of the Nentir Vale, the basic vanilla 4e setting (which by the way, feels cool, with some neat names for locations, a nice map -though way too small in the book- and so on). I feel the whole structure is progressive. It feels really heavy on the rules at times, but the book isn’t that big, so a player who’s already been hooked on the Player’s Book normally shouldn’t have a problem reading through this and hopefully, his imagination will fire up at the same time.

The Battle Map(s): This is actually a single, huge map which, on one side, depicts the dungeons of the Twisting Halls described in the DM’s Book, and on the other side, represents the wilderness surrounding the caves leading to the Halls on the surface. Now, a very neat trick introduced in the DM’s book is that the map is designed in such a way that you can actually cut it in four different parts that you then can reassemble to form different dungeon environments and layouts. Along with a little bit of imagination, you can actually play a handful of games just out of this map, which I thought was pretty cool. By the time you’re done with the map combinations, that you started to experiment with your own stuff drawn on some paper or white boards or whatnot, you’ll probably have upgraded your game to Essentials at least, which really is the point here. Thumbs up for this idea.

Character Sheets: There are four of them. The Essentials character sheet seems way simpler than the original 4e character sheet. It is reorganized. For instance, I like the way the skills are listed under their related ability score, rather than have ability scores in a box and a huge list of skills on the other side of the sheet or whatnot. Not too much information, nice balance. I like it. You can actually download the exact same character sheet from WotC’s website and print more of them for your friends.

Advertisement of D&D Essentials: Now, this is not just an advertisement. This is a double-sided sheet of paper that basically lays out what Essential product or book is destined for which type of player of the game: this or that product for players on one side, this or that product for the DM on the other. I think this could have been a much better advertisement sheet, unfortunately. I think its organization is more confusing than anything. It might give the impetus to look beyond the Starter Set and start searching for information on the web, say, or ask around in a gaming store, but it’s not a clear breakdown in and of itself.

That’s it. These are the contents of the D&D Starter Set, aka the new Red Box.

Image

More general thoughts

I am going to try and answer a few questions I can think of about this boxed set. Feel free to ask your own once I am done with this review.

I am new to RPGs, and wonder if this boxed set will help me get into D&D? This boxed set was made for you. It should provide you with good pointers to start with Essentials/4e D&D. I would encourage you to explore the game through this boxed set, upgrade to D&D Essentials when you feel like it, and/or from there explore other RPG venues to discover all the variety there is in game play, play styles, genres and more within the hobby.

I am a veteran gamer/role player and want to get into 4e D&D, is this boxed set for me? Not really. You can just skip this boxed set entirely and go directly to D&D Essentials instead. Pick up Heroes of the Fallen Lands, the Rules Compendium and/or the DM’s Kit and go from there.

Is this product Old School? No, it is not. For all intents and purposes, this is still D&D 4e. If you are not comfortable with things like skills in role playing games, tactical combat and encounters, and all these types of things, chances are, you will not like this boxed set, or D&D Essentials for that matter. BUT. There is a definite vibe of traditional D&D coming out of the whole thing. Not only in terms of themes or rules, mind you, but also when looking at the product itself.

The D&D Starter Set actually does not remind me so much about the Mentzer D&D Basic Set (the actual, original Red Box using the same cover art), since it is not a self-contained game system you can play on and on like you did with Mentzer D&D. Instead, it reminds me very strongly of Holmes D&D, the Blue Book of 1977. You were basically given a basic understanding of what the game is, how it plays out, along with enough rules to play a few games, all the while with the full expectation that, once done, you would upgrade to the full game system, AD&D First Edition in that instance. This boxed set here does the same thing here, with the expectation that you will upgrade to the full D&D Essentials once you’re done with it.

How does the Starter Set fit into the big picture? Well, there are some problems of compatibility between the Starter Set and the wider D&D Essentials. Some builds are not the same, powers change, that kind of thing. My advice is to simply rebuild your characters once you upgrade to D&D Essentials. They will be 2nd level by the time you are likely to upgrade. Not that big of a rebuild to make. This issue of compatibility seems to carry through to the very physical appearance of the product. It’s like the Red Box was designed well before the other components of D&D Essentials were finalized, including for instance decisions made regarding the format of the books, not just the rules. In that regard, the D&D 4e Gamma World boxed set with its digest-sized rulebook seems to actually fit more into the bigger picture than the D&D Starter Set does.

Does the D&D Starter Set accomplish its stated goals? As a product intended as a Starter Set, a box which introduces you to the game and expects you to upgrade to the full system after a while in the same way Holmes D&D did with AD&D back in the 1970s, yes, I think this product fulfills its purpose despite the discrepancies between the box’s contents and the wider Essentials D&D. As a self-contained D&D set like Mentzer D&D, which it is emphatically not, it fails miserably. The problem is that by using the original Red Box cover, it created this expectation on the part of many veterans of the game. There are no good or bad answers here, only a question of what you think this boxed set should do for you. If you want Mentzer D&D, you’ll be disappointed. If you don’t know what that is, or remember Holmes D&D, all the while accepting the fact that this version of D&D is not like the ones that came before, you might find a nice introduction to the core principles of the game.

Personally, I think this is a good product. Not perfect (there are mistakes and glitches and little things I didn’t like after all), but a product that will do some good for our hobby in the end - and that, I really cannot gather the strength or obstinacy to complain about.

My overall note for this product: 4 dice out of 5.

Well done, Wizards of the Coast. More of this in the future. Please.


Sat Oct 30, 2010 8:24 pm
Profile
User avatar

Joined: Sat Mar 14, 2009 3:32 am
Posts: 927
Location: Montréal, Québec
Post Re: Dungeons & Dragons Starter Set Review
Benoist wrote:
I am new to RPGs, and wonder if this boxed set will help me get into D&D?


Fuck no!

If you're new to RPGs, which would be surprising if you're reading this on the Haven, ignore the deceptively expensive crack model of 4e with their constraining electronic initiatives, terribly un-fun game and go right for pretty much any other RPG!

If you need the miniature crutch, something like Savage Worlds should do the trick. Cheapo, quick to learn and play.

If what you want is to really get into D&D, hunt down for out-of-print old editions. Think of 'em as you would think of CCM bicycles. The new ones still carry the brand and from time to time attempt to appeal to nostalgia but ain't worth shit as the company shifted priority from quality to profit-only. Same applies here!

The original Red Box, with the same cover but the better game would still be an excellent choice. The old Cyclopedia hardback would allow you to game indefinitely on just one book, for the price of the new introductory product to a lamer game. If you can't locate an OOP book, go for what they call clones or simulacrums. Just google "D&D retroclones" right fucking now and be enlightened! Or check games inspired by the original like Castles & Crusades or fuck, even Pathfinder!

The important thing to remember is that the new version sucks, is overcomplicated and will have a limited shelf life. While older versions are cleaner, simpler, self-contained and will allow you to play as long as you want.

_________________
FFHFKJFFKGJK

My mod voice is red


Sun Oct 31, 2010 12:16 am
Profile E-mail

Joined: Sat Mar 14, 2009 4:16 pm
Posts: 2855
Location: Crystal Lake, IL
Post Re: Dungeons & Dragons Starter Set Review
Benoist wrote:
The D&D Starter Set actually does not remind me so much about the Mentzer D&D Basic Set (the actual, original Red Box using the same cover art), since it is not a self-contained game system you can play on and on like you did with Mentzer D&D. Instead, it reminds me very strongly of Holmes D&D, the Blue Book of 1977. You were basically given a basic understanding of what the game is, how it plays out, along with enough rules to play a few games, all the while with the full expectation that, once done, you would upgrade to the full game system, AD&D First Edition in that instance. This boxed set here does the same thing here, with the expectation that you will upgrade to the full D&D Essentials once you’re done with it.

This is a really good analogy - and frankly one I should have come up with you bastard - given that I got my start with the Holmes blue box (with B1 - one of my favs).

_________________
The rules are my slave, not my master. - Old Geezer

I'm reaching out for something, touching nothing's all I ever do.

If you're interested in GaryCon


Sun Oct 31, 2010 10:53 am
Profile E-mail
User avatar

Joined: Sun Apr 12, 2009 10:42 pm
Posts: 925
Post Re: Dungeons & Dragons Starter Set Review
As I've mentioned in other threads, I like that the box is too big for the books, because that means if they sell me more books that I can use with this stuff, I can put it in the box. My Planescape books are all in the main box and the Chaos boxed set box.


Sun Oct 31, 2010 11:27 am
Profile E-mail

Joined: Tue Apr 28, 2009 12:50 pm
Posts: 1038
Post Re: Dungeons & Dragons Starter Set Review
Jim Skach wrote:
This is a really good analogy - and frankly one I should have come up with you bastard - given that I got my start with the Holmes blue box (with B1 - one of my favs).

Thanks!

It really started to hit me when I was in the middle of the character creation process in the Player's Book, and the more I thought about it, the more sense it made to me. Then, I read an interview of Mike Mearls somewhere who was directly linking Holmes D&D's design with the new Red Box's as a source of inspiration, and it seemed like a confirmation of that thought.


Sun Oct 31, 2010 12:19 pm
Profile

Joined: Sat Oct 03, 2009 9:56 am
Posts: 183
Post Re: Dungeons & Dragons Starter Set Review
Consonant Dude wrote:
Benoist wrote:
I am new to RPGs, and wonder if this boxed set will help me get into D&D?


Fuck no!
....


We get it, you hate 4e, go have a scotch and masturbate to the picture of the succubus in the 1e MM, you'll feel better. ;)

If someone's really new to RPGs, and they see this box in a big box retailer (where it is being sold, IIRC), this is far more likely to get them into RPGs than searching for out of print material. No one not already tied to a bunch of nerds like us posters is going to actively search out something like this. This has the instant appeal for parents that used to play, and D&D has enough name-recognition that it's likely to at least get a glance over from new players.

Say what you will about 4e, but arguing that this is a bad way to get new blood into RPGs is the most ridiculous thing I've heard all day.


Sun Oct 31, 2010 1:13 pm
Profile E-mail

Joined: Tue Apr 28, 2009 12:50 pm
Posts: 1038
Post Re: Dungeons & Dragons Starter Set Review
JDCorley wrote:
As I've mentioned in other threads, I like that the box is too big for the books, because that means if they sell me more books that I can use with this stuff, I can put it in the box. My Planescape books are all in the main box and the Chaos boxed set box.

I actually like the size of the box for that very reason. I tried fitting the Heroes of the Fallen Lands book and Rules Compendium along with all of the the box's contents, and you can.


Sun Oct 31, 2010 1:38 pm
Profile
User avatar

Joined: Sat Mar 14, 2009 3:32 am
Posts: 927
Location: Montréal, Québec
Post Re: Dungeons & Dragons Starter Set Review
Trevalon Moonleirion wrote:
We get it, you hate 4e, go have a scotch and masturbate to the picture of the succubus in the 1e MM, you'll feel better. ;)


That's more evidence of 1e's superiority! Which 4e illustration will the new generation use to choke the chicken? 8-)

Trevalon Moonleirion wrote:
If someone's really new to RPGs, and they see this box in a big box retailer (where it is being sold, IIRC), this is far more likely to get them into RPGs than searching for out of print material. No one not already tied to a bunch of nerds like us posters is going to actively search out something like this. This has the instant appeal for parents that used to play, and D&D has enough name-recognition that it's likely to at least get a glance over from new players.

Say what you will about 4e, but arguing that this is a bad way to get new blood into RPGs is the most ridiculous thing I've heard all day.


Context, Trevalon, context :)

I'm not arguing that 4e ain't gonna be a more successful entry point than clones or OOP material. I'm not doubting the power of branding for parents who used to play, the marketing savoir-faire and accessibility in shops or any of these things you mention.

We're on the RPG Haven. Presumably, this review is for people "tied to a bunch of nerds" like you said, or for a segment of consumers who like to do some internet searches before making purchasing decisions. (the latter bunch is probably statistically small but I believe still significant enough. Plus it's a smart thing to do to go beyond the marketing, whether you are talking about buying a computer, a game or car).

Anyways, those kind of people will be glad there are people like Benoist writing reviews and I hope, will appreciate the dissenting opinions to such reviews. It will probably not factor much statistically in the buying or "not-buying" of Essentials in a significant fashion but hey, it's still there for people to see.

Now, excuse me, I'm gonna go spank the monkey on the Succubus, while you rub yourself against a battle mat staring at grids :twisted:

_________________
FFHFKJFFKGJK

My mod voice is red


Sun Oct 31, 2010 2:28 pm
Profile E-mail

Joined: Tue Apr 28, 2009 12:50 pm
Posts: 1038
Post Re: Dungeons & Dragons Starter Set Review
Consonant Dude wrote:
Context, Trevalon, context :)

I'm not arguing that 4e ain't gonna be a more successful entry point than clones or OOP material. I'm not doubting the power of branding for parents who used to play, the marketing savoir-faire and accessibility in shops or any of these things you mention.

Well, the Q&A you commented on is specifically aimed at this. It is assuming a newbie to D&D and RPG knows just of the current edition of D&D because he/she saw the box in a store, or saw D&D Encounters in play or what not, and wants to give it a shot him/herself. The Q/A is basically answering by extension the question: "Will my little nephew who played a bit with me be able to start D&D 4e with this boxed set?" And there, the answer is most definitely "yes", to me.

After, if veterans of gaming, such as yourself, are more comfortable with this or that version of the game, and/or think it is preferrable to not introduce their nephew/children to gaming via 4e D&D, then this is another question, which I didn't get into in the review. I specifically did not want to go there because this is a completely peripheral (and frankly, totally hardcore gaming) issue compared to the merits of the boxed set itself.

PS: this review was also posted on the RPG Site, ENWorld, Circus Maximus and Wizards of the Coast's community website.

PPS:
Consonant Dude wrote:
Anyways, those kind of people will be glad there are people like Benoist writing reviews and I hope, will appreciate the dissenting opinions to such reviews.

I completely agree.


Sun Oct 31, 2010 2:49 pm
Profile
User avatar

Joined: Sun Apr 12, 2009 10:42 pm
Posts: 925
Post Re: Dungeons & Dragons Starter Set Review
I disagree with you, CD, about older D&D editions being inherently better than 4e for noobs. That's not to say that older D&D editions were bad at it - reality shows they were very good. But the key thing 4e brings to the table is concrete choice. This is something D&D has been good at in general since the start, but 4e takes it still further.

One of the big struggles for many new people in RPGs is making wide-open choices. D&D is great because you can go a very long way only making choices from a list. What race is your character, what class is your character, what weapon are you carrying, etc. The only wide-open choice in character creation is the character name, and guess what choice most new people struggle with most? The name.

4e gives new players a very thorough set of choices at each step during play. The structuring of skill challenges and combat actions is very discrete, and this is a good thing. An old-school D&D experience where you have to convince the GM that your plan, which you came up with on your own, is remotely sound and should be permitted to have a chance of succeeding, is not nearly as easy to understand/grasp/play.

But the first time a game tells me "you can do aaaanything you want", that's the moment when you're now on your own. If you get there too soon, then you'll be turned off to RPGs.


Mon Nov 01, 2010 10:01 am
Profile E-mail
Display posts from previous:  Sort by  
Reply to topic   [ 11 posts ]  Go to page 1, 2  Next

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: Google [Bot] and 1 guest


You cannot post new topics in this forum
You cannot reply to topics in this forum
You cannot edit your posts in this forum
You cannot delete your posts in this forum
You cannot post attachments in this forum

Search for:
Jump to:  
cron
Powered by phpBB © 2000, 2002, 2005, 2007 phpBB Group.
Designed by STSoftware.